Pit Boss Griddle Vs Blackstone Griddle: Which Should You Choose?


A griddle, which is a fantastic alternative to a traditional grill when cooking outdoors. You can cook items that a grill cannot, such as eggs, bacon, pancakes, and much more, all at once using this equipment.

Blackstone and Pit Boss are well-known brands when it comes to barbecues. Both the Blackstone 1666 and Pit Boss PB336GS are practical options that are reasonably priced.

Sunset Bar and Grill will compare the two products listed in this Pit Boss griddle vs Blackstone griddle comparison to see how they vary and whether one is the better bargain.

If you want to learn more about this, keep reading!

Pit Boss Griddle Vs Blackstone Griddle: Summary and Comparison Table

Product imagesProduct namesProduct HighlightsEditor's ratingPrice
Blackstone Tabletop Griddle, 16661.Brand: Blackstone
2.Material: Alloy Steel
3.Color: Black
4. Item Dimensions LxWxH: 22.5 x 19 x 9 inches
5. Item Weight: 32 Pounds
5/5 (best seller)
PIT BOSS PB336GS Pit Boss 2 Burner Table Top 1.Color: Black
2. Material: Stainless Steel, Cast Iron
3. Brand: PIT BOSS
4. Style: Modern
5. Item Dimensions LxWxH: 20.47 x 17.32 x 10.83 inches
6. Item Weight: 27 Pounds
4.5

Blackstone Vs Pit Boss Griddle: Which Is Better?

Pit Boss PB336GS Blackstone 1666 
Preview
Fuel Propane Propane
Burners 2 2
Total cooking area 289 square inches 339 square inches
Electric ignition Yes Yes
BTUs 15000BTUs 24000BTUs
Dimensions 20.47 x 17.32 x 10.83 inches 22.5 x 19 x 9 inches
Weight 27 pounds 32 pounds
Today’s Best Deal

We’ll compare the characteristics of the Blackstone and Pit Boss griddle in this section. We’ll also examine which one does a better job at cooking meals. Which griddle is the easiest to clean?

You will have a better understanding of griddles and will be able to choose the best one among them with ease.

1. Cooking Area

Cooking Area
The larger is not always the better

When choosing a griddle, the cooking area is the first thing to consider. It refers to the capacity to cook food on the griddle and the maximum amount of food cooked on its surface.

In this instance, the Pit Boss features a 289-square-inch frying pan, while the Blackstone features a 339-square-inch cooking area.

It indicates that they are of average size. The one from Pit Boss features a nonstick surface that is 4.7mm thick, while the Blackstone has a cold metal griddle top that warms up rapidly and evenly.

You may prepare lunch, breakfast, and supper on these griddle pans.

2. Burners

Both include two separate burners with temperature control dials that are adjustable.

With around 15000 BTUs of electricity, the Pit Boss warms the whole cooking surface, while the Blackstone’s H-style burners generate 24000 BTUs of energy.

H-style heaters help distribute heat evenly across a large area. They also include an electrical ignition button for quick and straightforward burner lighting.

3. Cooking Surface Material

A portable griddle
A portable griddle

For material, the cooking top of Pit Boss is made of cast iron, while the Blackstone is heat-rolled steel, which is more sturdy and heavyweight.

Because the cast-iron plate heats up faster, you may conserve gasoline. The meal will take less time for cooking than the Blackstone product.

4. Sturdy Construction

If you’re going camping or tailgating, the griddle must be manufactured of high-quality components that withstand high temperatures and rough conditions.

Both griddles are of sturdy materials. The Pit Boss is stainless steel and a cast iron griddle; the Blackstone is entirely stainless steel.

Although it is a heavyweight grill, it lasts an extended period. The one from Pit Boss is the ideal size for camping.

It has non-slip tabletop legs to be used on any ground. It is small, fits in a car, and may be taken when traveling.

5. Versatility

Blackstone product features an excellent heating performance
Blackstone product features an excellent heating performance

Which one is more adaptable? Both feature two burners and medium-sized griddles. To prepare seared steaks and pancakes, you can cook fries and saute veggies on the surface.

For lunch, breakfast, and supper, you can prepare any meal. The Pit Boss’s cast iron plate maintains more heat and delivers it evenly, making it ideal for thicker cuts of meat. Therefore, cooking steaks require less time.

6. Cleaning

Remember to clean it after each use while the surface is still heated because the grease container on the Pit Boss is easy to maintain.

For easy cleaning, the Blackstone incorporates an oil management system. So, you only need to clean the grease-catching pan.

What Is Blackstone Griddle?

What Is Blackstone Griddle
These cooking appliances are greater than they appear

Since 2005, Blackstone has manufactured griddles and is unquestionably the most well-known brand of outdoor kitchen appliances.

The company produces a variety of griddle types, giving customers a wide range of alternatives from which to select.

There’s one feature that all Blackstone griddles have in common: a top constructed of rolled steel that allows for equal heat dispersion.

Roasting on Blackstone products is a pleasing experience. The choices are unlimited, and the griddles have an enormous area and many burners so that you may cook items at various temperatures simultaneously.

Pancakes, bacon, patties, eggs, hash browns, and chicken, for example, can all be cooked simultaneously.

Blackstone griddles are available in four different sizes: 28 inches, 36 inches, 17-inch tabletop, and 22-inch griddle.

  • 17 inches

This product is ideal for those who need a portable cooking surface. It has ample surface area to prepare for five people.

Also, it is an excellent solution for those who are limited in space. It is not only a portable choice, but it is also simple to clean and operate.

  • 28 inches

If you’re going to serve medium parties, this grilling surface can be a decent choice. In this classification, the Blackstone griddle has a back grease/oil management system which makes cleanup a pleasure.

With many heat zones that can be adjusted, grills in this format are ideal for cooking a variety of meals at their ideal temperatures at the same time.

  • 36 inches

This is the best option for serving large groups and is ideal to become a focal point of the patio.

It includes everything you’ll need to master outdoor cooking. You can cook outside with any grill of this grill size without sacrificing taste or variety.

A Blackstone product might be a fun alternative to a grill if you enjoy cooking outside but are intimidated by it. You’ll receive a considerable cooktop to make many items at once, depending on the arrangement you choose.

The flexible burners enable you to make grilling zones that are separately regulated, making it simple to cook each item at the right temperature.

Overall, Blackstone products are fantastic and deserving of their reputation. Whether you have small patios or not, it will help you boost your outdoor grilling experience.

Blackstone Griddle Reviews

Blackstone 1666
Blackstone 1666

The Blackstone 22-inch griddle is a super-compact product from one of the most recognized firms in the market, and it appears to be entirely transportable.

With dimensions of 22.5 x 19 x 9 inches and a weight of under 32 pounds, it is clear that this device was ideal for the journeyman.

Whereas the 330 square-inch cooking surface and two burners with a combined BTU output of 24,000 may be small compared to other models, they should be plenty for a big group.

This grill also has adjustable heat zones and a back grease system, making it efficient when combined with exceptional mobility.

A grease route is integrated into the back grease system, pulling oil away from your meal. Its transportable design makes it simpler to move and makes it easy to operate.

Furthermore, the heavy-duty burners uniformly distribute heat throughout the cooking surface, ensuring that your meals are always perfect.

Furthermore, this machine is straightforward to set up, taking only 10 minutes. Therefore, cooking outside gets a lot simpler with this Blackstone tiny grill.

It works pretty quickly, and you won’t have to wait long for your meal to be ready. However, the draw tray is a bit on the small side. Moreover, some customers also claim that the cooking surface is not flat.

Pros:

  • Portable design
  • Fast operation
  • Easy to use and install
  • Distribute heat evenly
  • Feature an integrated grease tray
  • Adjustable heat zones

Cons:

  • Small draw tray
  • Non-flat cooking surface

What Is Pit Boss Griddle?

What Is Pit Boss Griddle
Pit Boss is well-known for the affordable cooking equipment

Pit Boss is among the fastest-growing grilling companies, with unique products that promise to flood the market.

Meanwhile, the company is best known for its fantastic pellet barbecues, it also offers a whole range of grills that claim to elevate your outdoor BBQs.

Pit Boss products achieve the ideal balance of power, mobility, and accuracy, resulting in a unique grilling experience.

Although these Pit Boss products are new to the industry, they’re a genuine game-changer, shaking the major brands, like Blackstone, to their core.

Their units include a nonstick hardened ceramic surface that ensures an unsurpassed, user-friendly operation.

The ceramic cooking layer not only helps clean the griddle a breeze but also safeguards the appliance from rust and scratches, ensuring that it maintains its attractive appearance.

While new to this business, Pit Boss products provide the highest value per sq inch. They offer a large selection of grills and griddles that are similar in size to these Blackstone ones. pit boss vs blackstone

Pit Boss Griddle Reviews

Pit Boss PB336GS
Pit Boss PB336GS

In some instances, a grill with a tiny cooking area is necessary. This grill is around 20.47 x 17.32 x 10.83 inches and weighs only 27 pounds.

As a result, it will be ideal for small-scale grilling demands. This device is for individuals who want a tiny cooking gadget to feed four to five people.

Therefore, if you’re one among them, this one with a 289-square-foot cooking space would be worth considering. You must be aware of the most excellent feature that makes purchasing this Pit Boss PB336GS a wise decision.

It is from cast iron or stainless steel. After bringing this Pit Boss into your house, you will not worry about purchasing a new barbecue for a couple of decades.

The 4.7 mm thick top has already been pre-seasoned and is perfect to use. So, there’s no need to spend so much time seasoning it.

There are a few more distinguishing characteristics as well. Pit Boss built it with four non-slip feet to provide good support to the entire body and make it non-slippery.

Aside from that, let us mention that both burners feature simple ignition mechanisms. They’re ready to go with only a single push.

However, you may have the issue of uneven thermal transfer throughout the cooking area.

Pros:

  • Easy to use and clean thanks to a grease management system
  • Feature a griddle top
  • Highly durable
  • Fast ignition

Con:

  • Uneven heat distribution

Things To Consider Before Buying A Griddle

Many individuals may not see purchasing a Blackstone or Pit Boss griddle as a one-time purchase. Before going out and buying one, like with any other expensive cookware, there are a few things you should think about

Here are several things to think about while selecting a griddle to carry home:

1. Cooking Surface

  • The coating is an important factor (Source: Trustedreviews)

Before purchasing a griddle, consider the metal and finish used in its construction.

Cast iron is used in some, whereas aluminum and various steel forms appear in others. The material of the plate impacts how easy it is to clean it and how evenly it heats.

The best material for your demand is whichever you are most comfortable with for cleaning. Choose a grill that will last a long time.

2. Storage Space

Aside from ensuring you have an adequate patio area for your griddle during the year, you also need to find a secure storage location for it while it is not in use.

If you do not have room for your griddle on the patio or in the garage, you’ll have to make some. Although the shelves are folded down, a grill may have a large base that will cover a lot of space.

You won’t have to worry if your grill is not kept secure between sessions with proper preparation of storage space. Importantly, if you’re going to keep it outside, you’ll need a lid to keep the rain off the cooking surface.

3. Thickness Of Plates

Thickness Of Plates
You should consider this factor

After deciding on the metal to utilize, you must also consider the plates’ thickness since different thicknesses have variable degrees of effectiveness.

The thin plates react faster than the thicker ones, significantly, whenever you change the temperature.

Unfortunately, when prepared at higher degrees, they may easily bend and transmit heat unevenly. The thick plates store much heat and disperse it more evenly throughout the period.

The disadvantage is that these cooking equipments are sluggish to react to temperature changes, requiring much energy to reach the target temperature.

Your preferences and budget will determine which choice is best for you.

Compare Brands

Choose from various brands on the market to see which one most impresses you. Before making a significant selection, think about each brand’s reputation, pricing, and other essential qualities.

Products from Pit Boss and Blackstone have a solid name in the griddle market.

Gas Vs Electric Griddle

Gas Vs Electric Griddle
Three setting dials

The most critical choice you’ll have to make is whether you opt for a gas or electric griddle. Gas products are more sensitive and can quickly detect temperature changes that are straightforward to adjust.

The electric product is simple to set up, even without the help of a specialist, and it’s also simple to move about when in use.

Ease Of Cleaning

This factor will allow you to devote more time to more important concerns. Choose the one that is composed of easy-to-clean materials.

Oil management systems are standard on Pit Boss and Blackstone griddles, making cleanup a breeze.

Kitchen Requirements

Kitchen Requirements
Choose the suitable size for your kitchen

This factor will assist you in determining the optimum size for your kitchen. You can also discover any additional equipment or kitchen accessories you’ll need when utilizing the griddle.

Size

You may buy the most suited for good based on your demands and space. Various heat zones must be available in larger units to provide energy efficiency and flexibility.

However, size does not imply superiority. As a result, select one that you feel will meet your requirements.

FAQs

Here are some frequently asked questions we have collected while researching this field. We hope all of these are beneficial to you in deciding the best product for your kitchen.

1. Is A Blackstone Griddle Worth It?

Blackstone grills are well worth the investment. The most crucial factor in evaluating is if the griddle or grill will meet your demands.

Blackstone is worth it if you seek a huge cooking surface and long-lasting, high-quality equipment.

2. What Is A Pit Boss Griddle Made Of?

The griddle top, which is built of 4.7mm cast iron, lives true to Pit Boss’ title of “Hotter. Bigger. Heavier.” It retains heat efficiently and maintains an equal, consistent temperature throughout the cooking process.

3. Are Pit Boss Grills Any Good?

It is effortless to operate, and the steaks we prepared were delicious. Because we reduced the heat, another side had a more robust smoky flavor, but it still produced steaks that tasted like they were grilled over charcoal.

The item is built to last and is rather hefty. You’ll need help taking it out of the box if you’re not particularly strong.

4. Is Pit Boss Worth The Money?

It is a fantastic place to start if you’re looking for a low-cost pellet barbecue. Pit Boss produces a high-quality product with a cooking experience that is significantly superior to that of a standard grill.

The signature line includes simple grills. They are not particularly sophisticated, but they are ideal for grilling with the family.

5. How Long Do Pit Boss Grills Last?

If you take care of your Pit Boss, it will survive for decades. It comes with a five-year guarantee, but the ceramic materials should last much longer if you buy a cover and clean it regularly.

6. Are Steaks Good On A Griddle?

That’s perfect! It is among our favorite steak preparation methods, and the results are fantastic.

All you have to do is an essential seasoning to give your steak a lot of flavors, and then you can cook it on a griddle pan on the stovetop.

7. Where Are Pit Boss Grills Made?

Pit Boss is from China.

8. What Is The Best Blackstone?

The best Blackstone grill will be dependent on your requirements. In this comparison, you can refer to the Blackstone 1666 since we appreciate it for the best value.

9. Can You Cook With The Lid Down On A Blackstone Griddle?

Cooking thick chunks of meat with the lid down ensures an even finish, so having a cap is an excellent method to make sure you can cook anything to perfection, no matter what it is.

10. Does Blackstone Make An Electric Griddle?

Electric griddle from Blackstone is now available for indoor and outdoor grilling. The innovative rotate and detach glass hood protects your kitchen while trapping heat for steaming and cooking.

11. What Size Blackstone Griddle Should I Get?

If you are on a budget and only need to feed a small party of 3-5 people, the 28-inch is the way to go.

If you need the one that can cook enough meals for a large group, a 36-inch griddle is a better choice. Besides, the 28-inch product is portable camping equipment.

Which griddle is best Blackstone or Pit Boss?

The Blackstone 1666 is unquestionably the superior griddle, but the Pit Boss PB336GS is cost-effective and efficient because it costs roughly half.

Moreover, the Blackstone 1666 gas grill is the best overall tabletop griddle because it is more beneficial for cooking. Since it boasts a larger cooking area and a greater BTU output, you can prepare more food in less time.

If you want more bang for your buck, the Pit Boss PB336GS is the superior choice. It costs roughly half as much as the Blackstone 1666, and although it wasn’t quite as productive, it still cooks meals quickly.

This cooking equipment is also lighter and smaller, making it easier to transport for camping, picnics, and other outdoor activities.

We hope this Pit Boss griddle vs Blackstone griddle comparison helps you a lot in deciding which one will be your companion.

Thank you for reading!

Leave a Comment